Giveaway of the Day Forums » Games Discussion

My review of Brave Dwarves: Back for Treasures (set 5)

(12 posts)
  • Started 10 months ago by Lockett
  • Latest reply from Lockett

  1. Lockett
    Member

    My review of Brave Dwarves: Back for Treasures (set 5):

    Before I begin this review, let me say this: THIS GAME IS HORRIBLE. It's like what Magnussoft would have made on a higher budget. The object is to run through several excessively large caves, collect all three keys, find the door, and exit the level. It's a pretty similar concept to that of the Turtle Odyssey games that were given away this week and last, but the execution is appalling. For starters, the controls are the most unintuitive that I've ever had to use in a platformer. The keys are redefinable, but that doesn't change the triangular jumping, or the fact that your character stops every time that you attack. If you go near a bat, it will fly maniacally back and forth. If you don't kill it, it will push you everywhere that it flies. There are few things more annoying than that, but there are. For example, it's an incredible feat to be able to jump off of the edge of one platform onto another. You think that you're at the edge, but when you jump, you just fall down - even though you were touching the edge. This, coupled with the sheer size of the levels, and their designs, which constantly force you to do the same basic tasks over and over again, make it the antithesis of what a platformer should be.

    The graphics are nice - for 1998. Three different art styles are used in each level: cartoony drawings for the dwarves, odd-looking Photoshop collages for the tiles, and low-definition 3D models for the enemies. None are particularly well-done. The tiles' edges don't even line up! If I called this amateurish, I'd be insulting amateurs.

    The sound is similarly dismal. Take Magnussoft's bland sound effects and add dull ambient techno, and you have Brave Dwarves: Back for Treasures. Needless to say, it isn't particularly likeable in any way.

    The basic story is that the portal between the dwarf world and some other place(maybe Hell, like in Doom) has been opened and treasures are required to fix it. If the stupid story wasn't bad enough, they included walking skeletons as enemies, maybe to be a bit more mainstream(read: hopelessly generic). The techno music doesn't fit in, either.

    Overall, I give Brave Dwarves: Back for Treasures (set 5) a score of three and a half out of ten(three for gameplay, four for graphics, four for sound, and three for theme). It could have been half decent, but it's simply botched.

    Small side notes:

    When the game is run, it shows a splash screen with the message: "Press any key to continue". Why should I have to do anything to get to the main menu? The menu itself, by the way, is awful.

    Couldn't they just call this Version 5.0 or something? "Set 5" makes it sound like an expansion pack.

    Posted 10 months ago #
  2. goodgotd
    Member

    and not a quote from the previous giveaway of this?

    http://game.giveawayoftheday.com/dwarves-back-for-treasures-set-5/ -
    June 2, 2007

    well, here's one:

    Brave Dwarves - Back for Treasures (Set 10) was offered on GGAOTD way back at 11th of April.

    call it a slow GGAOTD day?

    Posted 10 months ago #
  3. Whiterabbit-uk
    Games Guru

    I have to disagree with you on most points you've made as several children playing this and other brave dwarves sets in preference to other games and I do have a very large and somewhat over the top selection) can't be wrong. They've moved on to other games now though as too many sets does make a series jaded. Prof Fizzwizzle is one of their favorites now, but only because it's got a levels editor. They seem to really enjoy making their own levels, lol.

    I much preferred their more polished Brave Dwarves 2 as one point I do agree on is the dated graphic - well okay - maybe two points - because the music doesn't fit either.

    Still you've written a good review Lockett.

    WR

    Posted 10 months ago # | Login to Send PM
  4. Lockett
    Member

    >Whiterabbit

    Your poor kids obviously haven't played Cave Story. Here's a real game:

    http://megaupload.com/?d=2O9X2ZIB

    And the officially sanctioned fansite:

    http://miraigamer.net/cavestory/

    Aside from having great level design, fluid controls, beautiful (pixel)graphics, wonderful (chiptune)music, three endings, and an engaging storyline, there really isn't much reason to recommend it. I think that you and your kids would like it, though.

    Posted 10 months ago #
  5. Whiterabbit-uk
    Games Guru

    Thanks for the link Lockett, I'll certainly give the game a whorl to see if it lives up to expectations. ;)

    I would never actually buy any of the Brave Dwarves games from either of the series as I'm quite happy with what platforms my family have already bought, most beong of the quirky type such as Wik or Gish, as I love unusual games.

    Posted 10 months ago # | Login to Send PM
  6. Lockett
    Member

    Well, we can agree on at least one thing: Gish is awesome!

    Posted 10 months ago #
  7. Whiterabbit-uk
    Games Guru

    I didn't think we disagreed on virtually everything. For example most of the games you listed in your favorite games I actually like.

    To be honest, I only play arcade games when I need a rest from the more intensive games such as the FPS, RPG, RTS and simulation games I play. I only download most of the games from the giveaway project for my children as before that most of the arcade games i had apart from a few were adult orientated. Thanks to the giveaway project my kids have a much wider range of games they can and like to play.

    With respect to our different reviews. I think its a really good thing to have reviews that are often poles apart as it gives the community a much better idea as to what to expect. No matter how I try to make my reviews unbiased I think it's really hard not to let my own likes and dislikes creep into my conclusions a little.

    I do enjoy reading your reviews even though I may often disagree with them. You write very well.

    I fell in love with Gish the first time I played it. I promised I'd rewrite the editors read me files over on the Gish forums at Chronic Logic, as the one you get with the game is appalling, but I’m still writing my Battlefield 2 review, which is well over 1200 pages in length. It's more like a Battlefield 2 encyclopedia, devoted to the single player fraternity as it lists every single player map available for the game divided into the different mod’s available, with download links, images and reviews of each map together with a complex hyperlink network to make the whole thing user friendly. I still intend to rewrite the editor manual for Gish though as the game is well worth it. Besides my kids want me to make some new levels for them. The ones I tried to build were rubbish as I hadn’t quite got the hang of some of the functions. Have you downloaded all the extra content from the fan site?

    Posted 10 months ago # | Login to Send PM
  8. Besides, if everyone agreed with everyone..Life would get really boring, really fast. :)

    I like Lockett's reviews as well.

    Posted 10 months ago #
  9. funkymom
    Member

    it's great to have reviews with different point of views, because reviews, by their very nature, are biased.

    my opinions,likes & dislikes are not going to be exactly the same as either of you (or anyone else who might join the critics). so by reading several opinions, i am able to get a bigger picture of the program, and it becomes easier to make a decision.

    thank you whiterabbit and lockett!

    Posted 10 months ago #
  10. Whiterabbit-uk
    Games Guru

    IT's a pleasure Funkymom - everytime I write your name I remember the way I spelled it the first time, which gave away my nationality, lol

    Posted 10 months ago # | Login to Send PM
  11. funkymom
    Member

    i happen to like brits. :D

    Posted 10 months ago #
  12. Lockett
    Member

    I happen to like Australians. :D

    Posted 10 months ago #

RSS feed for this topic

Reply

You must log in to post.